NTSB Docket Regarding Accident that Killed Two Metro Employees Released

On January 26, 2010, at about 1:40 am, two of my coworkers in Automatic Train Control (ATC) were killed when a ‘hi-rail’ truck (a pickup truck that can operate on both the highway and rails) backed over them.  Their names were Jeff Garrard and Sung Oh.  Both were married and had children.

They were replacing an impedance bond between Rockville (A14) and Shady Grove (A15) on track 2 (the outbound track).  The truck that hit them was operated by Track dept. employees who were setting up their ‘work zone’.  They were operating the truck in reverse (which is routine) traveling inbound on track 2.  The truck did have lights on the rear which were apparently working (judging from the NTSB docket) but the backup alarm was not operating.  We found out after the accident that Metro ordered the hi-rail truck equipment mfr to design the truck so that the alarm would only operate when the truck was in reverse and _off_ the rails.  It is silent when on the tracks.  To my knowledge, no explanation has been given for this.

Here is a photo of the truck:

The NTSB docket can be found here.

At this point it seems to be a ‘he said, she said’ situation.  Central Control (OCC) and the Track dept. employees are pointing fingers at each other.  No one is taking responsibility.  The transcript of the radio communications will probably clear things up, but that has not been released.  We will probably have to wait for the final report from the NTSB.

I will have a lot more to say about this in the future, but for now, if nothing else, everyone who thinks they are “covered” by Workers’ Comp insurance (WC) should know this:

If your employer has WC and they or your coworker(s) KILL you, they cannot be sued by your spouse, your family, or your estate.  They are IMMUNE from all lawsuits.  Even if your death is a result of gross negligence, negligence that under any other circumstances would result in the guilty party having to serve serious time in prison.  WC is a trade-off.  You (the employee) agree to give up your right to sue for wrongful injury or death in exchange for a type of no-fault coverage.  It’s actually a good deal for those who are accident prone — they can injure themselves and be totally 100% at fault and still get all medical expenses paid as well as at least a portion of their lost wages.  For everyone else it’s a bad deal.  It’s particularly bad in certain states that limit the amount of death benefits.  For example, in MD, if the surviving spouse is considered to be only “partially dependent” then WC benefits are capped at something like $75,000.  If the deceased spouse made $37,500 then the WC benefits stop after 2 years.  If they made $75,000 they stop after one year.  So not only can the employer not be sued, the deceased employee’s family may very well end up destitute.

“Sorry about your dead wife/husband.  Move along now.  Buh-bye!”

Very few people seem to realize this.  I didn’t until Jeff and Sung were killed.  Since Metro spans 3 jurisdictions (MD, VA, D.C.) there is a huge disparity in how the surviving spouses of the employees Metro has killed are treated.  Many receive less compensation than a plaintiff with a broken arm in a typical slip and fall lawsuit against Metro.  Passengers can sue, employees can’t.

Metro is the 51st State, but this is the same with any employer that has WC insurance.  It is something that clearly needs to change.  It is outrageous that an employer, government agency, or their employees can actually KILL someone and skate.  More than one attorney told me that the only way for an employer to be successfully sued is if they essentially admit to premeditated murder — in court, in front of a judge.  In this case, management at OCC would have to say something like, “Yes your honor, I purposely instructed the operator of the truck to proceed down the track knowing full well that the two ATC technicians were there.  I owed them money and wanted them dead.”  Of course, accidents like this rarely rise to he level of premeditated murder, and even if they did the responsible party will never admit it.  WC is a license to maim and kill with impunity.

This entry was posted in Management Follies, Safety Incidents, The Metro Hall of Shame and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to NTSB Docket Regarding Accident that Killed Two Metro Employees Released

  1. I’ll bet that very few people know this about WC. I didn’t know it until you enlightened me. Thanx for the info Sherm. I love reading your blog. The really sad thing about this is that WC costs employers a lot of money, but in the end it does so very little to help employees. Between WC and UC we would pay more than $5,000 a year to cover people and we are not big enough to afford it. We have to have people sign WC waivers instead of being able to cover them.

  2. dmented says:

    There are “hidden” laws/rules within government agencies that a lot of employees are not aware of. WC sounds as if they may be among those agencies. It’s sad that these “policies” exist within government. Do you think a corporation or business could get away with having these in place? However not as drastic as the above article, I was once clearly discriminated against by a government agency. I called the government discrimination hotline and their answer was “Due to identity of the discriminating party (a government agency), you need to call a private attorney. We can’t process a case against ourselves.” The only outcome I sought was an investigation into the incident to make sure it didn’t happen to me or someone else again.

    • My understanding is that workers’ Comp insurance (WC) shields _all_ employers (not just government agencies) from lawsuits. Most employees in America are covered by WC. They have all forfeited their right and their spouse’s right to sue should they be injured or killed on the job. Most people do not realize this. To use Metro as an example, a passenger could slip an fall and break a finger and likely get more money from a lawsuit than the spouse of an employee who was _killed_ as a result of gross negligence by Metro.

      The response you got to your discrimination complaint is ridiculous! This may be an obvious question but what is the point of the discrimination hotline? Was it just for employees of private companies? Your only recourse was to hire an attorney?!

      Years ago I experienced some potential discrimination at Metro. I contacted the WMATA (Metro) EEO office and to their credit they took my complaint seriously and the situation was resolved. Of course, since Metro is the 51st State, what I experienced is likely different from how most government agencies operate. Since Metro makes their own rules and answers to no one, they have their own EEO office that does ‘process a case against themselves’. Kind of strange now that I think about it…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s